Marsh,+Debora

Judge's Name: Debora Marsh High School Graduation Date: I'm really old Judge's e-mail: marshd@dexterschools.org Experience: - Coach a team - Teach a high school class Rounds Judged this topic: 0 except for in class debates Judge Paradigm: Policymaker Rate of Delivery: 3 Moderate Quantity of Arguments: 3 A moderate number Topicality: 3 Moderately Counterplans: 3 sometimes acceptable Generic Disadvantages: 3 sometimes acceptable Conditional Negative Positions: 3 sometimes acceptable Debate Theory Arguments: 3 sometimes acceptable Kritik arguments: 4 usually unacceptable Overall judging paradigm: Generally I am a director, tab worker. I don't really judge any more and if you do end up with me in a round, as a lot of questions before you start to find out how I feel about something. I have become more about substance and persuasion and less about trickery. I will vote on my flow, so if I tell you to slow down or become clearer, you should probably take my advice. I most likely will look to to how you end up weighing the magnitude, the probability and the time frame of the impact debate. I don't like to make decisions for you, so if you don't make them I'm unlikely to do the work for you.