Medford-Conley+(Tow),+Pamela

Judge's Name: Medford-Conley (Tow), Pamela High School Graduation Date: 1988 Judge's e-mail: pmedford@fhps.net Experience: - Coach a team - High School debater - College debater - Frequently Judge - Teach a high school class Rounds Judged this topic: 12 not counting in class and scrimmages Judge Paradigm: Stock issues Rate of Delivery: 5 Fast Quantity of Arguments: 4 Relatively many Topicality: 2 Moderately often Counterplans: 1 acceptable Generic Disadvantages: 2 usually acceptable Conditional Negative Positions: 2 usually acceptable Debate Theory Arguments: 1 acceptable Kritik arguments: 2 usually acceptable Overall judging paradigm: I will listen to any argument but I want them applied to a stock issue. Tell me why the K outweighs the Harm on the impact calc or why the counter plan solves better. I am fine with critical and performance affs but they need to affirm the resolution and they need to read a plan text. I will vote of K's but they need to have an alternative to the plan solvency and "reject" is not an alternative. Speed is fine as long as you are clear and if you aren't I will tell you while you are speaking. Tag teaming in CX is fine but be polite - always polite.

Ethics Statement: Agree